Last night I had my first encounter with the inside of a holding cell.
I was whisked away from the protest marking the 5th anniversary of the War in Iraq by a police man who undoubtedly arrested me for the sole purpose of scaring the crowd back onto the streets. At first I didn’t realize what had happened. I was one of the people who wasn’t supposed to get arrested. I hadn’t lain down in the streets or spray painted any circled A’s on the IRS building. But regardless I was frisked and crammed awkwardly into the back of a police car.
As the car began to pull away I asked repeatedly what I had been arrested for. "You’re being charged with disorderly conduct for blocking traffic" was the response I kept receiving. "Blocking traffic? But I was only about a step away from the curb, and I wasn’t the only one standing there." There must have been about 10 others standing in what they then told me was technically the street. I had been assuming that I was standing in parking space, after seeing two cop cars pulled over at the side of the road. I later found out that the cops knew who I was and were well aware that I was very active in the student movement. It was for this reason that I was targeted to be arrested.
I was brought to the parking lot of Strong Museum (known as "the museum of play" ironically) where I heard 7 others had been arrested. I imagine this was just to regroup and figure out how many had been arrested. Out of the window I could see the top of Jeff’s bald head, a local RAW and ISO member who had come to check up on us and make sure everything was going alright. The police asked me a few repetitive questions, to which I responded in only my finest English. I wanted to try to break down any effort to dehumanize me that the pigs may been attempting, consciously or unconsciously.
Sweet as apple pie, I began to chum around with the officer in the front seat. "My name is Jake, by the way" I said to him. I received no reply. "So... you guys drive Impalas, huh?" Again, no response. Part of my talking may have been to merely keep myself calm and try to forget that I was immobilized in the back of a police car.
We parked next to another cop car in the parking lot of the museum. From where I sat I was able to see Sister Rita, one of the others who had been arrested, in the car next to us. We exchanged glances, giving each other the biggest grins our anxious faces could muster, which calmed me even further. I had never realized how uplifting being with your comrades could be when you are arrested.
Finally we were taken to the Monroe County Jail where we were processed, photographed, heckled, badgered, questioned, and promptly tossed into a holding cell -- of course not before being called a "dirty hippy" and other verbal abuses that I had believed weren’t in use since the Vietnam era.
The whole place smelled like urine and chlorine. I remember sitting in what I considered a "waiting room" especially for prisoners being brought in, and asking again what my official charges were. The officer on the bench across from me said "you were blocking traffic (which was false). We only did it for your safety." I couldn’t help but laugh under my breath at that. It’s interesting how those in power will always say that "it’s for your own good" when trying to justify their position of privilege. I turned to Harry, one of the other arrestees who was brought in shortly after me and noted what a resemblance that statement bore to the rationale for maintaining the centralized State. .
I was so happy to find the face of one of my comrades, Eli, in the cell I was taken to. At this point we had the cell all to ourselves and began thinking of all the outrageous things we could do to fuck with the guard’s heads. I suggested perhaps having a dance party. He declined after saying "they’d be expecting that."
And, again, the talking began. For the first half hour, I kept up a constant conversation with Eli. If at any point there was a lull, I noticed my brain racing for a new topic to talk about. I felt sorry for him after a few minutes, realizing that I had nearly gabbed his ear off, but I also began to notice that I was a little less tense.
After a long wait, Mike was brought in, followed shortly by Harry. There the four of us sat, exchanging stories and waiting for the others to show up. By that time we had figured out that it was Kathy and two local nuns, Sister Grace and Sister Rita, had been the remaining three who had been detained. We saw them brought in, given their phone calls, and walked past the cell to another unit. I was disappointed to find out the women were to be kept in separate facilities.
But none-the-less, the party ensued. We all told stories about our past, political or otherwise, laughing as if sitting on a park bench in Washington Square Park. I had almost forgotten that we were in a holding cell aside from the fact that from where I was sitting you could see the pigs walking arrogantly past the Plexiglas window. I asked aloud "How can these motherfuckers walk around here spitting in these people’s faces, and then go home and raise their children and pretend they’re a decent human being?"
Then I began noticing the race structure of the facilities. As I looked out the window, I saw that nearly all the inmates were black, and every one of the guards I saw was white. In fact, everyone who worked in the building was white, aside from one heavy set nurse I saw at one point.
It began getting late, and we asked repeatedly for mattresses -- mattresses that were visible from our cell, perhaps twenty feet away. I was hungry, dehydrated, and had no where to sleep, aside from the 2 inch thick benches that we were sitting on. The water that came from a corroded fountain in the cell tasted like metal, and should any of us have to go to the bathroom, they were forced to stand behind a waist-high wall that jutted out only a few inches past the side of the toilet, and which had no front covering.
A few others were brought in to the cell, but they are not worth talking about in any detail. The only part of that which should be noted is that their presence hardly changed the interaction between those who had been arrested at the rally, and in fact we talked freely with those who were brought in.
After spending about five hours in the cell, an officer opened the door and called out my name. I was brought to a desk near by and was allowed to retrieve the items which had been taken from me. Everything in this institution was slow. It took nearly twenty minutes to go get my things, sign a single paper, and exit the holding facilities.
As I waited behind the steel-reinforced green door, images of an infuriated 120 pound WASPy-looking mother rushed through my head. "I’m going to open this door, and there she’ll be." I almost wished I could stay in the cell.
Suddenly, a loud "click" rang out through the chamber and the door was opened. I peered through to find 10 fellow activists waving red and black flags, with balloons, cake, and other assorted foodstuffs. And no mother! I managed to hold back tears after realizing how many comrades I had that truly cared about me.
I was free, and headed back to my friend Ted’s house to sleep and wait for my arraignment the next day.
Comments
Re: My Short Time in Jail
03 Apr 2008
You may think your protest was enpowering and "world changing" but the truth is it wasn't. Most people who are opposing the war are looking towards the next election where there vote will count. The protests -- both big and small-- have been ineffective in changing one iota of how this war has been run. This protest movement would be much more effective if you were actually doing something to help the world rather than waving your signs and your banners! For instance:
1. Gathering and providing school supplies for Iraq's children. The smarter those kids are the better off they will be and the more effective they will be in running their country.
2. Providing food and supplies to needy countries. Poverty is the main cause of upheaval in the developing world. If the people have adequate supplies and are living a better life it will prevent dictators and other despots from gaining power.
3. Protesting and encouraging the boycott of the next olympics in china -- a country were there are numerous human rights abuses.
4. Designing new ways for people to car pool and mass transit initiatives so that we can be less dependant on foreign oil.
Just imagine if you spent five years working on one of these rather than holding your idiotic sign!!!
Re: Re: My Short Time in Jail
05 Apr 2008
Example!
"You may think your protest was enpowering and "world changing" but the truth is it wasn't."
"Protesting and encouraging the boycott of the next olympics in china -- a country were there are numerous human rights abuses."
Take your crap elsewhere.
Re: Re: Re: My Short Time in Jail
05 Apr 2008
Ted-
Re: My Short Time in Jail
07 Apr 2008
And its strange that some people find my opinion so divisive that they would like me to leave while at the same time participating in a site that invites free speech!
What's wrong? Don't you like a place where you can have a fair and reasoned argument where we can discuss ideas in an open way?
The suggestions that I made in the first reply are real and valid ways to attack the issues at the heart of the war in a much more effective way than standing on the side of the road with a sign -- or getting arrested for carrying that sign into the roadway.
Right now people are attempting to stop the olympic torch from staying lit and reaching China. These people are getting media coverage and continually bringing up the issues of human rights abuses in china. Sponsors have already pulled out of the olympic games -- if all goes well one of two things will happen:
1. With the glare of the media at its borders China changes its ways and adopts a free and open democracy (unlikely).
2. The rest of the world will come to realize the danger of dealing with china under its current government and fight for change (more likely). The sooner companies like google and youtube and everyone else allow chinese people open and complete access to the web the more information the chinese people will get and that knowledge will be able to start a revolution of ideas that will change the face of china and the world forever!
Secondly if you wish to prevent future ways in Afghanistan or Iraq the people need to be educated. The sooner they are the better off they will be. Start a book drive, start a school supply drive. There are many places all over the world that have benefited from free and open education.
I stand by this. You may think that standing by the side of the road off and on for five years somehow effected change -- well it didn't. You may have thought getting arrested effected changed -- it didn't. People in Rochester and all over the world have been driving past your protests for 5 years and frankly we don't care about you or your signs or your protests because they lack meaning and substance. Your only slightly less annoying than the guys who stand outside of cell phone stores at the mall asking me what sort of plan I'm on.
Re: Re: My Short Time in Jail
08 Apr 2008
I'm curious how well you know the person who wrote the account? How do you know what he is and isn't engaged in? Your responses indicate that perhaps you know very little.
Have you considered the potential of mass direct action? One memorable action was the demonstrators who shut down the port in Olympia, WA--putting themselves in harms way to literally stop the transport of military weapons.
That's one small example. Check out Indymedia.us for a more national perspective. Or read some radical history for a much greater perspective of what's possible when people act together in solidarity.
Sure, he was one person who was made an example of by the police--but if more people took action then who knows what might be accomplished. Of course there are those that enjoy complaining behind their computer screens about other people taking action that they feel is ineffective, illegitimate, or annoying--when it appears that they aren't engaged in anything but prattling on the web. Diversity of tactics and solidarity are important. You'll notice I'm not condemning your suggestions--but more is needed beyond reforms, band-aids, and declarations.
What was your name?
Ted-
Re: Re: My Short Time in Jail
10 Apr 2008
The problems in Iraq and Afghanastan are mostly the result of us bombing the crap out of them and then occupying them with soldiers.
If anything America is the country that needs better education. We were the ones who caused this problem. This, is of course, unless the education you are speaking of involves primarily war tactics, self defense , and weapons technology. That is the only type of education that Iraq and Afghanastan could have used to stop their current situation. But even so, its a little late for that and not sure many people would support giving these countries that type of education.
But in all seriousness, I think the Iraqi people would prefer not being killed to receiving a few extra books.
And if you read the story you're commenting on, he didn't try to get arrested. The police arrested him because he stepped into the street (not to block traffic, he just stepped off the curb). I step into the street all the time and it's not because I want to get arrested. It was a bullshit charge and your blame the victim mentality makes it harder to take you seriously.
Re: My Short Time in Jail
09 Apr 2008
And yes more people would make your efforts more effective -- but people do not want to invest themselves in your methods and we're beyond the time frame of saying that these people may be unfamiliar with who you are, your intentions and your methods. They know your methods, they know your intentions and they know who you are and yet they have decided not to join in--
the reason: your methods are ineffective. And when I say your methods i mean the rochester anti-war movements methods.
The local antiwar movement does not inspire me to action.
I do not see the benefit of your/their work when the results are so small.
And that there efforts could be better used if focused on other antiwar activities that can and do produce quantifiable results.
-jason
Re: Re: My Short Time in Jail
10 Apr 2008
Like complaining on the internet? Come on, what do you think should be done? (And why aren't you doing it?)
And to the person who says we should protest China instead:
Of course it is easy to only engage in fair weather protests like the anti-China protests where the media is actually on your side. But as long as everybody is protesting other countries and not looking at the actions of their own, NOBODY will fix their own country.
Yes, what China is doing is wrong, but so is what our own country is doing and if everybody gives up opposing it just because it's easier to protest China, because the cops act like assholes if you protest your own country, or because the mainstream media tries to screw you every chance it gets, then this war will never end.
So, Go Protest China. Seriously, I'm all for it, and you seem to be too. China is doing a lot of nasty shit, and if you think you can stop them, go ahead. But don't criticize people who protest the war just because you don't think they're accomplishing something. There's one guaranteed way to accomplish nothing and that's too never try.
The problem isn't people like Jake, because whether or not they are doing everything right, they are at least doing something. The problem is all the armchair protesters who sit and home on their computer and complain that everyone else is doing things wrong but refuse to do anything themselves.
-Another protester
Re: My Short Time in Jail
11 Apr 2008
What I am saying is that your antiwar efforts of protesting downtown -- holding signs -- and performing theatrical skits is not working and has not worked for 5 years. You have wasted 5 years worth of time doing something that has garnered no results. It is not that the community doesn't support some or all of your goals and it is not that the media is against you -- far from it. But they have an understanding of events that you do not.
Namely that your methods have not worked. And any ridicule that you get is because your methods have not worked in changing the state of the war.
Everyone is looking towards their election and planning on making their vote count. And through the democratic process people will most likely be elected based on their plans for the economy and the war. I believe this next election will end up ending the war as we know and understand it.
There are so many good people out there helping to make the Iraqi people self-sufficiant so that they can determine their own destiny and we never have to be on their soil again. Right now people are packaging up school supplies for Iraqi children so that those little boys and girls will be better educated than their parents. Right now medical supplies are being gathered by non-profits and shipped into Iraq so that people can get the health care they need rather than relying on the militants who extort support from others through the hording of medical supplies and food. Right now American citizens are educating others on what Islam is so that we can undertand their culture and traditions and not be afraid of a culture that is different than ours.
so what have you been doing with your time?
Was holding that sign for 5 year's worth it? You could have been doing one of the above things and actually changed someone's life and perceptions. It's a shame really that you do not see how your type of action is really inaction.
"The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results."
-jason
Re: Re: My Short Time in Jail
14 Apr 2008
Not everyone, Jason. I know a lot of people who are pissed off and disillusioned with these political and economic systems. To say "Everyone" is pretty disingenuous. I hope you're right about the next election ending the Iraq war, but I'm not holding my breath. Also, it's not just this war that needs to end, but all wars.
"There are so many good people out there helping to make the Iraqi people self-sufficiant so that they can determine their own destiny and we never have to be on their soil again."
I'm not sure if you know history, but Iraq wasn't a war torn and impoverished area before we came. They had a tremendous literacy rate and some of the best healthcare out there--comparable to our own. It was only after we started lobbing and dropping bombs on them (civilians, hospitals, power plants, water facilities--all war crimes) that they're whole existence changed. They had self-determination--one reason we invaded--before we invaded.
"Right now people are packaging up school supplies for Iraqi children so that those little boys and girls will be better educated than their parents. Right now medical supplies are being gathered by non-profits and shipped into Iraq so that people can get the health care they need rather than relying on the militants who extort support from others through the hording of medical supplies and food. Right now American citizens are educating others on what Islam is so that we can undertand their culture and traditions and not be afraid of a culture that is different than ours."
Your charity crap really annoys me, by the way. It's pretty Orwellian, no? US tax payers give money to the government to lay waste to sovereign nations so predominantly US-based private corporations can go in and rebuild their country at theirs and our expense. Then, we have the folks who want to "make a difference" through "feel good acts" of charity and then go around complaining that the world hates us after all we've done for them. It makes me sick.
"so what have you been doing with your time?"
I noticed that you never really explained your role in things. You use amorphous terms like "people," "non-profits," and "American citizens" to talk about all the good we're doing. Then you ask what have I been doing. I'm not going to address that question because I don't think it's fair. If you wanna ask what I've been doing, tell me what you've been doing and leave the amorphous crap out of it.
Thanks!
Ted-